Lately there has been a lot of hoopla surrounding a few states that have started to enact voter ID laws. To me the issue boils down to a very simple question; ‘Who should get to vote?’ We have several supreme court cases that fairly definitively answer that any US citizen who has not lost their voting rights due to criminal activity should be allowed to vote. Thus we have to determine if voter ID laws really prevent citizens from voting?

Personally I can only think of 2 reasons that requiring a photo ID to vote might actually be preventative for citizens. 1) it generally costs a fee to receive a photo ID, and 2) some people can not have a photo ID due to religious reasons. I don’t think that you should have to violate your religion to vote, but I think that if you were to bring the same documents that it would take to get an ID (proof of citizenship and residency) you should be allowed to vote. Also if a state is going to require an ID for voting, they need to provide some sort of ID for free to citizens for the purpose of voting.


Beyond the previously mentioned issues, I see no problem with requiring someone to show reasonable proof that they are a citizen to be able to vote. Requiring someone to show that they are eligible for a right is much different in my eyes from preventing them for exercising that right.